Our Menu

Appetizers

Calamari

Fried spinach, lightly dusted calamari with spicy aioli

$17.00
Crispy Parmesan Wings (Spicy)

Baked, fried, tossed ina buffalo parmesan mild sauce, with garlic aioli

$14.00
Bonless Wings

Crispy, tender boneless chicken wings tossed in your choice of buffalo parmesan or orange chicken sauce

$14.00
Housemade Meatballs (2)

Meatballs, meat sauce, blend of cheeses, parmesan cheese

$10.50
Toasted Ravioli

Housemade by Nonna’s served with meat sauce

$12.50
Cottleville Crab Cakes

Two 3oz house made crab cakes, pan seared and served with spicy aioli for dipping and a fresh lemon squeeze

$18.00
Toasted Cannelloni Bites

Blend of beef and pork, wrapped in a cannelloni shell covered in italian bread crumbs with tomato basil dipping sauce

$12.50
Cheese Curds

White cheddar garlic beer battered cheese curds with tomato basil dipping sauce

$12.50
Lobster Rangoon

With spicy aioli

$12.50
Cottleville Sliders

Two mini beef patties with melted American cheese, and

our signature sauce on toasted brioche buns

$10.00
Cheese Garlic Bread

Italian bread dipped in garlic parmesan butter baked with blended cheeses

$8.00
Soup of the Day

Bowl

$8.00

All salads served with hot Italian garlic bread. Add roasted chicken, fried chicken, seasoned shrimp, or calamari $6.


Dressings

House (Sweet Zesty Italian), Housemade Mayfair, Ranch, Bacon Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette

Extra Dressing & Sauces .75¢

Take home a quart of our Homemade Mayfair OR House Dressing for $12.00

Salads

Goat Cheese Spinach

Spinach, goat cheese, strawberries, spicy walnuts, red onions, raspberry vinaigrette

$13
Caesar

Romaine hearts, housemade croutons, parmesan, housemade mayfair dressing

$6 / $12
House

Iceberg, provel cheese, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, housemade croutons, parmesan, sweet zesty Italian

$6 / $12

ALL SANDWICHES SERVED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF:

SIDE SALAD, TATER TOTS, SHOESTRING FRIES, OR SIDE OF PASTA:

TOMATO BASIL, MEAT SAUCE,

WHITE SAUCE OR PINK SAUCE

Menu

Handcrafted Favorites

Paulie

Roasted beef, provel, garlic mayo on ciabatta with side of au jus

$17.50
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Lightly breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella served on cheese garlic bread

$17.50
Cottleville Sliders

Three mini beef patties with melted American cheese, and our signature sauce on toasted brioche buns

$17.50
Mahi Mahi Fish Tacos

Blackened mahi mahi in warm tortillas, aioli slaw topped with avocado lime sauce

$21.00

Add side salad $4. Split charge $4.

Menu

Pasta

Lasagna

Thin layered pasta, meat sauce, blend of cheeses

$21.00
Cannelloni (3)

Beef cannelloni baked with meat sauce, blend of cheeses, pink sauce

$20.50
Seafood Cannelloni (3)

Stuffed with lobster, scallops, shrimp and topped off with garlic shrimp, cream sauce and blend of cheeses

$23.50
Manicotti (3)

Cheese manicotti baked with tomato basil, blend of cheeses, cream sauce

$18.50
Beef Tortellini

Bacon, asparagus tips with garlic cream sauce

$20.50
Spaghetti or Rigatoni

Meat sauce, tomato basil or cream sauce

Add shrimp, chicken or 2  meatballs $6

$16.00
Garlic Shrimp Rigatoni

Garlic shrimp, cream sauce, roasted red peppers, fried spinach

$24.00
Pasta Primavera

A medley of fresh zucchini, squash, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes and spinach in pesto sauce

Add Shrimp $6 Add Chicken $6 Combination $6

$21.00
Cajun Penne Pasta

Cajun cream sauce, red onions, roasted red peppers

Add Shrimp $6 Add Chicken $6 Combination $6

$17.00
Pasta Con Broccoli

Pink sauce, broccoli, mushrooms. Add Chicken $6

$17.50

Add side salad $4. Split charge $4.

Entrées

Eggplant Parmesan

Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, blend of cheeses, served with tomato basil pasta, roasted asparagus

$23.50
Chicken Parmesan

Lightly breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella served with tomato basil spaghetti, roasted asparagus

$23.50
Chicken Modiga

Lightly breaded chicken, with a white wine lemon butter sauce and a blend of cheeses, crispy bacon and fresh mushrooms. Served with olive oil butter garlic pasta, roasted asparagus.

$25.00
House Specialty Chicken Spiedini

Chicken spiedini over olive oil butter garlic spaghetti with grilled asparagus, topped with lemon butter sauce

$23.00
Baked Salmon

Eight ounce filet with brown sugar dry rub served with broccoli

$23.00

Sides

Broccoli
$8.00
Roasted Asparagus
$8.00
Fried Spinach
$8.00
Bowl of Fries
$8.00
Mini Loaf Garlic Bread
$1.50
Bowl of Tater Tots
$8.00
Pasta w/Tomato Basil
$8.00
Pasta w/Meat Sauce
$8.00
Pasta w/White Sauce
$8.00

Pizza

Homemade Shells
Small 12" - $14 & XLarge 16" - $19
10" Gluten Free Crust is available $14

Cheese

Choice of: Provel, Mozzarella, or a Blend

Toppings

Red Onion

Mushrooms

Artichokes

Black Olives

Tomatoes

Green Peppers

Fried Spinach

Fresh Garlic

Pineapple

Jalepeno

Banana Peppers

Roasted Red Peppers

Fresh Mozzarella

Blue Cheese Crumbles

Goat Cheese

Sausage

Pepperoni

Hamburger

Crispy Bacon

Meatballs

*Grilled Chicken

Cajun Shrimp

$6/$9

Additional Toppings: Small $1.95 / XLarge $2.95

All specialty pizzas served with blend of mozzarella and provel unless otherwise stated

Specialty Pizzas

Meat Lover’s

Hamburger, crispy bacon, sausage, pepperoni

$19 / $27
Cajun Shrimp (Spicy)

Our signature cajun cream sauce base, roasted red peppers, red onions, cajun shrimp and topped with grated parmesan

$19 / $27
Deluxe

Sausage, peperoni, black olives, mushrooms, onions, green pepper

$19 / $27
"Timmy’s"

Meatball, fresh mozzarella, red onions, banana peppers

$19 / $27
Margarita

Pesto sauce base, fresh mozzarella, basil leaves and sliced tomatoes

$19/$27
Veggie Delight

Mushrooms, roasted red peppers, onions, black olives, fresh garlic, goat cheese, topped with fried spinach

$16 / $24
*Buffalo (Spicy)

Fried chicken, blue cheese, hot sauce, drizzle of ranch

$19 / $27

ASK ABOUT OUR REWARDS PROGRAM

Soups and Housemade Desserts

Automatic gratuity added to groups of 6 or more.

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.